Timing is Everything: Interval Algebra for Smarter Time Series Analysis

Data Science, Engineering

“The bad news is time flies. The good news is you’re the pilot.” — Michael Altshuler

Understanding Interval Algebra: Applying it to Time Series Data

Time series data is the backbone of applications across industries, from finance and healthcare to logistics and technology. When working with temporal data, it’s often important to not only handle individual time points but also to understand and analyze intervals of time—spans with a defined start and end. This is where interval algebra comes into play, offering a powerful toolkit to examine relationships between time intervals in complex data sets. In this post, we’ll explore interval algebra, its historical foundation, and how to apply it to time series data with examples in T-SQL and Python.

A Brief History of Interval Algebra

Interval algebra was introduced by cognitive scientist James F. Allen in 1983 to describe temporal relationships in natural language understanding. Allen’s foundational work, “Maintaining Knowledge about Temporal Intervals,” provided the basis for describing qualitative relationships between time intervals. Allen’s interval algebra specifies 13 possible relations between any two intervals, which are foundational for applications ranging from AI planning to temporal reasoning in databases.

Allen’s work allows developers and data scientists to ask nuanced questions about how intervals relate to each other, enabling them to model temporal events in a variety of fields, including scheduling, event sequence analysis, and time series data management.

Allen’s 13 Interval Relationships

Allen’s interval algebra defines 13 possible relationships between two intervals AAA and BBB:

  • Before: AAA ends before BBB starts.
  • After: AAA starts after BBB ends.
  • Meets: AAA ends exactly when BBB starts.
  • Met-by: BBB ends exactly when AAA starts.
  • Overlaps: AAA starts before BBB and ends after BBB starts but before BBB ends.
  • Overlapped-by: BBB starts before AAA and ends after AAA starts but before AAA ends.
  • Starts: AAA and BBB start at the same time, but AAA ends before BBB.
  • Started-by: BBB and AAA start at the same time, but BBB ends before AAA.
  • During: AAA starts after BBB starts and ends before BBB ends.
  • Contains: BBB starts after AAA starts and ends before AAA ends.
  • Finishes: AAA starts before BBB and ends at the same time as BBB.
  • Finished-by: BBB starts before AAA and ends at the same time as AAA.
  • Equals: AAA and BBB start and end at the same time.

These relationships form the foundation for querying and analyzing temporal relationships in time series data.

Applying Interval Algebra to Time Series Data

Interval Algebra in T-SQL

T-SQL provides a robust framework for handling interval algebra concepts, especially for time series data stored in SQL databases. Here’s how we can use T-SQL to identify relationships between two intervals:

-- Creating a sample table for intervals
CREATE TABLE Intervals (
    interval_id INT PRIMARY KEY,
    start_date DATETIME,
    end_date DATETIME
);

-- Inserting sample intervals
INSERT INTO Intervals (IntervalID, StartDate, EndDate)
VALUES (1, '2024-01-01', '2024-01-10'),
       (2, '2024-01-05', '2024-01-15'),
       (3, '2024-01-10', '2024-01-20');

-- Example: Identifying intervals that 'Overlap' with a given interval (ID = 1)
SELECT 
     a.interval_id AS IntervalA, 
     b.interval_id AS IntervalB
FROM intervals a
JOIN intervals b ON a.interval_id <> b.interval_id
WHERE 
     a.start_date < b.end_date 
     AND a.end_date > b.start_date;

This query joins intervals on the condition where one interval starts before the other ends and ends after the other starts, capturing the “Overlaps” relationship.

Interval Algebra in Python

Python, with its datetime module and libraries like pandas for handling time series data, offers a flexible environment for implementing interval algebra.

Python Code Example

Here’s an example of defining intervals and checking their relationships using basic logic:

from datetime import datetime

# Define intervals with start and end times
interval_a = {'start': datetime(2024, 1, 1), 'end': datetime(2024, 1, 10)}
interval_b = {'start': datetime(2024, 1, 5), 'end': datetime(2024, 1, 15)}

# Function to determine the relationship between two intervals
def interval_relation(a, b):
    if a['end'] < b['start']:
        return "Before"
    elif a['start'] > b['end']:
        return "After"
    elif a['end'] == b['start']:
        return "Meets"
    elif a['start'] == b['end']:
        return "Met-by"
    elif a['start'] < b['start'] and a['end'] > b['start'] and a['end'] < b['end']:
        return "Overlaps"
    elif b['start'] < a['start'] and b['end'] > a['start'] and b['end'] < a['end']:
        return "Overlapped-by"
    elif a['start'] == b['start'] and a['end'] < b['end']:
        return "Starts"
    elif a['start'] == b['start'] and a['end'] > b['end']:
        return "Started-by"
    elif a['start'] > b['start'] and a['end'] < b['end']:
        return "During"
    elif b['start'] > a['start'] and b['end'] < a['end']:
        return "Contains"
    elif a['start'] < b['start'] and a['end'] == b['end']:
        return "Finishes"
    elif b['start'] < a['start'] and b['end'] == a['end']:
        return "Finished-by"
    elif a['start'] == b['start'] and a['end'] == b['end']:
        return "Equals"
    return "Unknown"

# Test the function
relation = interval_relation(interval_a, interval_b)
print(f"The relationship between Interval A and Interval B is: {relation}")

This function evaluates each of Allen’s interval relationships using straightforward comparisons, allowing you to classify the relationship between any two intervals in Python.

Practical Applications of Interval Algebra

Using interval algebra, you can efficiently manage and analyze time intervals in time series data. Common use cases include:

  • Event Sequencing: Determining if one event meets or overlaps with another in scheduling applications.
  • Resource Allocation: Managing resources that are allocated over specific time intervals, ensuring no double-booking.
  • Temporal Reasoning in AI: Applying temporal logic to model dynamic situations, such as predicting traffic congestion based on past intervals of high demand.

Interval algebra gives you the tools to create queries and algorithms that understand the “when” of your data—how different events or states interact over time.

Wrapping it up…

Interval algebra provides a structured way to reason about intervals in time series data, empowering you to make meaningful connections across data points that represent spans of time. By understanding and applying Allen’s 13 interval relationships, you can tackle complex temporal reasoning tasks in SQL databases or Python environments, opening the door to enhanced insights and efficient time-based data management.

Whether you’re scheduling resources, analyzing historical data, or building temporal models, interval algebra is a valuable conceptual framework for reasoning about time.

Must Read